Comparison of Flame Retardant Standards for Electric Wires and Cables

 

Electric Wires and Cables

Introduction

With the increasing demand for fire safety in electric wires and cablesflame retardant standards play a critical role in preventing fire hazards and the spread of flames. This paper compares the domestic and international flame retardant standard systems, focusing on GB/T 19666-2019 and GB 31247-2014, and analyzes the key technical indicators, sample burning methods, and combustion test parameters.


1. Current Standards for Flame Retardant Cables

1.1 International Standards (IEC 60332 Series)

  • IEC 60332-1-1:2015IEC 60332-1-2:2004, and IEC 60332-1-3:2004 focus on the flame spread height based on non-metal content in cables.
  • China adopts these standards through GB/T 18380-2022, which aligns with IEC 60332.

1.2 Chinese National Standards

  • GB/T 19666-2019: General rules for flame-retardant and fire-resistant electric wires and optical cables.
  • GB 31247-2014: Classification for burning behavior of electric and optical cables.

2. Key Technical Indicators Comparison

2.1 Assessment Items

StandardAssessment Items
GB/T 19666-2019Carbonization height ≤ 2.5 m
GB 31247-2014Heat release, smoke generation, flame spread, and burning growth rate

2.2 Sample Burning Quantity

Flame Retardant LevelNon-Metal Volume FractionMinimum Number of Samples
AF/R Class7.04
A Class7.02
B Class3.52
C Class1.52
D Class0.52

2.3 Binding Method for Sample Bundles

StandardBinding Method
GB/T 19666-2019Based on conductor cross-section area and cable diameter
GB 31247-2014Determined solely by cable diameter

2.4 Combustion Test Time

StandardCombustion Time
GB/T 19666-201940 min for AF/R, A, B Classes; 20 min for C and D Classes
GB 31247-201420 min for all levels

3. Challenges in Standard Implementation

3.1 Airflow Control During Combustion

  • Air intake flow rate and airflow direction significantly impact test accuracy.
  • Maintaining 8000 L/min airflow stability is essential for consistent results.

3.2 Burner Position and Stability

  • Positioning the burner at a 75 mm distance from the sample affects heat release rate.
  • Clogged nozzles due to residue buildup can lead to inaccurate readings.

3.3 Environmental Temperature Control

  • Standard requires 5°C to 40°C ambient temperature with 16 hours of pre-treatment at (20±10)°C.

4. Conclusion and Recommendations


  • GB/T 19666-2019 focuses on preventing flame spread, while GB 31247-2014 emphasizes heat release and smoke production.
  • For high-rise buildings and subwaysGB 31247-2014 provides better fire safety protection.
  • Cable manufacturers should customize cable structure and materials to meet different flame retardant standards.



5. Keywords

  • Flame Retardant Cable Standards
  • Fire Performance of Electric Cables
  • Heat Release and Smoke Control
  • IEC 60332 and GB Standards

6. References

  1. Zhao Di (2024). Comparison on Flame Retardant Standards of Electric Wires and CablesWire & Cable, No.6, 2024. DOI: 10.16105/j.dxdl.1672-6901.202406009
  2. GB/T 19666-2019 - General Rules for Flame Retardant Cables
  3. GB 31247-2014 - Classification for Burning Behavior of Cables

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Understanding Voltage Levels and Cable Types in China's Power Industry

What Are Trailing Cables and Where Are They Used?

Understanding Low Voltage Power Cables: A Comprehensive Guide

Medium Voltage Cable Life Expectancy: Factors and Insights

4 AWG Wire: Definition, Specifications, Ampacity, and MM² Equivalent

Optimized Design of Smooth Aluminum Sheath Thickness for High-Voltage Cables Using the Short-Circuit Capacity Method

0.6/1kV CU/XLPE/PVC Cable

Residential Wiring: Types, Gauges, Wires, and Standards

Single-Core Wires: Applications and Functionality

All Cable Products-Henan Province Jianyun Cable Co., Ltd.